How an AI Bot Named James Replaced My Job: A Personal Account
The Unexpected Transformation at The Garden Island
It felt surreal to realize that the AI bot named James replaced my job at The Garden Island. I remember vividly how difficult it was for this local Hawaiian newspaper to hire reporters. Whenever someone left, it often took months to find a replacement, if one was found at all. The staff was stretched thin, covering stories across the island of Kauai, which has a population of around 73,000 people. So, when I saw the announcement that the paper had hired new “journalists,” I was curious. Little did I know, the replacements were not human at all.
We strongly recommend that you check out our guide on how to take advantage of AI in today’s passive income economy.
Table of Contents
The Arrival of AI Presenters
Last Thursday, as I tuned in to the paper’s broadcast from a spacious studio overlooking a picturesque tropical beach, I encountered James and Rose for the first time. James, a middle-aged Asian man, appeared to have a robotic demeanor with unblinking eyes. Rose, a younger redhead, struggled with basic pronunciation, mispronouncing names like “Hanalei” and “TV.” Their broadcast, set to an upbeat tune reminiscent of the Challengers score, was unsettling. James’ hands trembled uncontrollably, while Rose’s mouth often failed to sync with her words. It was clear that something was off.
Behind the AI Avatars
The truth behind James and Rose was even more startling. They are not real journalists but AI avatars created by Caledo, an Israeli company. Caledo aims to revolutionize local news by providing AI-powered broadcasts that simulate live conversations between digital hosts. According to Dina Shatner, who co-founded Caledo with her husband Moti in 2023, their technology is designed to make news presentation more engaging. “Watching someone read an article is boring,” Shatner says. “But watching people talk about a subject—this is engaging.”
The Technology and Its Promise
Caledo’s platform analyzes prewritten news articles and converts them into live broadcasts featuring interactions between AI hosts. Unlike other companies that use AI avatars solely for reading articles, Caledo’s platform allows for conversational exchanges. This technology aims to give small local newsrooms the ability to produce live broadcasts they otherwise couldn’t afford. It also promises new advertising opportunities and appeals to younger audiences who prefer dynamic content over static articles.
Viewer Reactions and Feedback
However, the reception of these AI-generated broadcasts has not been entirely positive. Comments on Instagram reveal that many viewers are not impressed. One comment read, “This ain’t that,” reflecting frustration with the lack of authentic local journalism. Another user simply stated, “Nightmares.” Despite these critiques, Caledo’s technology found its first U.S. partner in The Garden Island, which quickly adopted the AI broadcast system.
The Financial Struggles of Local Newspapers
When I worked at The Garden Island, the paper seemed far from innovative. Its website was outdated, and the financial situation was precarious, with declining advertising revenue. The Garden Island, the oldest and only daily print newspaper on Kauai, was struggling to maintain even a small team of reporters. The paper had been passed between several media conglomerates over the years, including a recent acquisition by Carpenter Media Group. This ownership change brought new opportunities but also new challenges.
Caledo’s Expansion and Local Adaptation
Caledo is expanding its AI broadcast technology to other papers under Carpenter Media. The company tailors its AI avatars and studio backdrops to match each publication’s style and demographics. For Kauai, Caledo designed a Hawaiian beach-themed studio and chose an Asian avatar to resonate with local demographics. They even attempted to train the AI on Hawaiian pronunciations, though errors persisted. For instance, Rose repeatedly mispronounced “hale” (house) as “hail.”
The Role of AI in News Reporting
Caledo asserts that its AI technology doesn’t replace existing jobs but fills gaps where human reporters are not present. At The Garden Island, the AI bots like James and Rose are providing a service that wasn’t offered before. Each broadcast starts with a clear disclaimer about the AI nature of the hosts, aiming to prevent confusion among viewers. While the cost of the technology remains undisclosed, the hope is that new advertising opportunities will offset the expense.
Community Acceptance and Challenges
The critical question remains: will local audiences embrace AI presenters? Early feedback suggests resistance, especially from Kauai residents who may find it difficult to accept James and Rose as local figures. One local woman described the AI broadcasts as “creepy,” and Padraic Gallagher, another resident, criticized the length of the broadcasts. The pauses for advertisements and the back-and-forth between James and Rose often made the shows longer than reading the articles would have taken.
The “Uncanny Valley” Effect
Felix Simon, a researcher from the University of Oxford, points out that the “uncanny valley effect” might contribute to the negative reception of AI presenters. This phenomenon describes the discomfort people feel when interacting with entities that closely resemble humans but are not quite right. Simon also notes that local news broadcasters often build personal bonds with their audiences, a connection that AI cannot replicate. “The thought that this gets replaced with something machine-generated will likely sit uneasy with some,” Simon explains.
The Future of AI in Journalism
AI is increasingly making its way into the journalism industry, despite mixed reactions from readers. Some newspapers are using AI for mundane tasks like generating article summaries or conducting research. In other cases, entire articles are written by AI without human input. This shift towards automation has led to further layoffs in some newsrooms, raising concerns about the impact on audience trust and the quality of journalism.
Building Trust in Local News
The challenge of building trust between local news outlets and their communities has always been significant. Local newsrooms, already weakened by layoffs, struggle to create genuine connections with their audiences. In places like Kauai, where staff members are often from the mainland, it’s even harder to establish a deep understanding of local issues. The high cost of living and low salaries contribute to a cycle where journalists cannot stay long enough to build lasting relationships with the community.
The Human Touch in Journalism
One former reporter from The Garden Island shared a sentiment that resonates with many. She feels that investing in AI broadcasts instead of real human reporters is “gross.” In communities of color and tight-knit localities, building trust requires human interaction—something that AI, like James, cannot provide. “You can’t have a conversation with James the AI bot,” she says. “He’s not going to show up at events.”
In conclusion, the rise of AI bots like James represents a significant shift in the journalism industry. While the technology offers new possibilities for local newspapers struggling with financial constraints, it also raises questions about authenticity, trust, and the role of human journalists. As AI continues to evolve, its impact on the news industry and its audience will be closely watched.
We strongly recommend that you check out our guide on how to take advantage of AI in today’s passive income economy.
